法国开发署贷款陕西省宝鸡市凤翔区东湖雍城湖湿地治理项目（考古遗址与自然景观保护与发展）第5包：博物馆建筑群总包（初步设计+施工图设计+施工+采购）（重新招标）评标结果公示

项目名称：法国开发署贷款陕西省宝鸡市凤翔区东湖雍城湖湿地治理项目（考古遗址与自然景观保护与发展）第5包：博物馆建筑群总包（初步设计+施工图设计+施工+采购）（重新招标）

招标编号： 0733-23090492

选择方法：技术标与财务标综合评估

业主名称：宝鸡市凤翔区林业局

招标代理：中信国际招标有限公司

一、评标情况：

1. 投标人名称：中交建筑集团有限公司、中国航空规划设计研究总院有限公司联合体 

技术综合得分：0.58分

财务综合得分：0.34分

综合得分：0.92分

投标报价（不含税/欧元）：30,484,997.95

评标价（不含税/欧元）：30,484,997.95

未中标理由：实质性响应招标文件要求，但综合得分排名第二。

2. 投标人名称：陕西建工第一建设集团有限公司与重庆大学建筑规划设计研究总院有限公司联合体

技术综合得分：0.65分

财务综合得分：0.35分

综合得分：1分

投标报价（不含税/欧元）：29,973,953.15

评标价（不含税/欧元）：29,973,953.15

中标理由：实质性响应招标文件要求，且综合得分最高。

3. 投标人名称：中国建筑第六工程局有限公司、中国建筑上海设计研究院有限公司

技术综合得分：/

财务综合得分：/

综合得分：/

投标报价（不含税/欧元）：/

评标价（不含税/欧元）：/

未中标理由：根据招标文件第一章第4.2款的规定：“投标人不应存在利益冲突，发现存在利益冲突的任何投标人均不合格......”和招标文件第二章 ITB 4.2的规定：“2）......其中本合同包的潜在投标人若与本项目第1包总体方案设计包（除大遗址）的中标人（包括联合体牵头方和成员方）直接或间接的共同处于他人控制之下，则被视为利益冲突。”（详见补遗（三）），评标委员会经讨论后一致认为，该投标人与本项目第1包总体方案设计包（除大遗址）中标人之间存在利益冲突，不能满足招标文件第三章 评标和资格标准“2.资格要求”1.合格性中的“1.2 利益冲突”的要求，因此不能通过资格审查。并根据招标文件第二章ITB14.1&14.2规定：“投标人应满足第三章的资格要求。在对技术投标文件和投标报价进行评审之前，应当先对投标人资格进行评审。不满足“第三章评标和资格标准”的投标人其投标将被拒绝。”。综上，该投标人未能通过资格审查，投标被拒绝。

二、中标人及合同授予情况：

三、提出异议的渠道和方式：

各投标人或其他利害关系人如对以上公示结果存有异议，请在本项目公示期结束前，即自本结果发出起三（3）个日历日内（至2023年9月28日午夜止），以书面形式（投标授权代表签字并加盖公章）将相关异议提交至业主单位和招标代理公司（联系方式如下）。

业主单位：宝鸡市凤翔区林业局

联系人：李红英

地址：陕西省宝鸡市凤翔区雍城大道中段

电话：+86-917-7219650

邮箱：bjsfxqxmb@126.com

招标代理公司：中信国际招标有限公司

联系人：杨庚旭、郭欣悦

地址：北京市海淀区中关村南大街1号友谊宾馆苏园17单元四层

电话：+86-10-68946709

邮箱：yanggx@biddingcitic.com, guoxy@biddingcitic.com

  中信国际招标有限公司

                                 二〇二三年九月二十五日

Announcement of Bid Evaluation Results of Lot 05: Museum complex EPC (preliminary design + construction drawing design+ construction + procurement)（Rebidding）of Dong Lake & Yongcheng Lake Wetland Restoration Project of Fengxiang District, Baoji City, Shaanxi Province (Protection and Development of the Archaeological and Natural Site) Financed by Agence Française de Développement

Project Name: Dong Lake & Yongcheng Lake Wetland Restoration Project of Fengxiang District, Baoji City, Shaanxi Province (Protection and Development of the Archaeological and Natural Site) Financed by Agence Française de Développement Lot 05: Museum complex EPC (preliminary design + construction drawing design+ construction + procurement)（Rebidding）

IPC No.: 0733-23090492

Selection method: Evaluation of Combined Technical and Financial Bids

Employer: Fengxiang District Forestry Bureau of Baoji City

Procurement Agent: CITIC International Tendering Co., Ltd

I. Evaluation Situation:

1. Name of the Bidder: Consortium of CCCC Construction Group Co., Ltd. and China Aviation Planning and Design Institute (Group) Co., Ltd. 

Technical Comprehensive Score: 0.58 points

Financial Comprehensive Score: 0.34 points

Comprehensive Score: 0.92 points

Bid Price (excluding taxes/ Euro): 30,484,997.95

Evaluated Bid Price (excluding taxes/ Euro): 30,484,997.95

Reasons for why not selected: The bid is substantially responsive but the comprehensive score ranked second.

2. Name of the Bidder: Consortium of the SCEGC No.1 Construction Engineering Group Co., Ltd. and Research Institute of Architectural & Planning, Design Co., Ltd, Chongqing University

Technical Comprehensive Score: 0.65 points

Financial Comprehensive Score: 0.35 points

Comprehensive Score: 1 point

Bid Price (excluding taxes/ Euro): 29,973,953.15

Evaluated Bid Price (excluding taxes/ Euro): 29,973,953.15

Reasons for why selected: The bid is substantially responsive and got the highest comprehensive score.

3. Name of the Bidder: China Construction Sixth Engineering Bureau Corporation Limited and China Shanghai Architectural Design & Research Institute Co., Ltd.

Technical Comprehensive Score: /

Financial Comprehensive Score: /

Comprehensive Score: /

Bid Price (excluding taxes/ Euro): /

Evaluated Bid Price (excluding taxes/ Euro): /

Reasons for why not selected: As specified in 4.2 in Section I of the bidding documents, “A Bidder shall not have a conflict of interest. Any Bidder found to have a conflict of interest shall be disqualified......”. As specified in ITB 4.2 in Section II of the bidding documents, “2) ......If a potential bidder of Lot 05 and the successful bidder (including the leading party and any member party of the JV) of Lot 01: Global programming for the whole project (except archaeological sites programming) of this Project are directly or indirectly under the control of a third party, it will be considered as a conflict of interest” (see Addendum (III)). Through discussion, the bid evaluation committee concluded that the Bidder has a conflict of interest with the successful bidder of Lot 01: Global programming for the whole project (except archaeological sites programming) of this Project. Therefore, the Bidder can not meet the requirements of “1.2 Conflict of Interest” in “1. Eligibility” in “2. Qualification Requirements” in Section III - Evaluation and Qualification Criteria and thus fail to pass the qualification examination. And according to ITB 14.1&14.2 in Section II of the bidding documents, “Bidders shall meet qualification requirements specified in “Section III - Evaluation and Qualification Criteria”. Bidder’s qualification shall be evaluated before evaluation of the technical part of bid and the bid price. Bids which are not compliant with the requirements of Section III shall be rejected.” Based on the above mentioned, the Bidder failed to pass the qualification examination and its bid is rejected.

II. The Successful Bidder and Contract Award Information:

III. Channels and Methods for Raising Objections:

If any bidder or other interested party has any objections to the above publicity results, please submit the relevant objections in writing (signed by the authorized bid representative and stamped with the official seal) to the Employer and Procurement Agent (contact information is as follows) within three (3) calendar days (until midnight on September 28, 2023) from the issuance of this result before the end of the publicity period of this project.

Employer: Fengxiang District Forestry Bureau of Baoji City

Attention: Ms. Li Hongying

Address: Middle section of Yongcheng Avenue, Fengxiang District, Baoji City, Shaanxi Province

Telephone: +86-917-7219650

Email: bjsfxqxmb@126.com

Procurement Agent: CITIC International Tendering Co., Ltd.

Attention: Mr. Yang Gengxu, Ms. Guo Xinyue

Address: 4/F, No.17th Unit, Su Yuan, Beijing Friendship Hotel, Haidian District, Beijing

Telephone:+86-10-68946709

Email: yanggx@biddingcitic.com, guoxy@biddingcitic.com

CITIC International Tendering Co., Ltd.    

September 25, 2003